Charnockite: The Rock Named After Calcutta’s Supposed ‘Founder’

Charnockite is a coarseโ€‘grained, orthopyroxeneโ€‘bearing granite first identified in southern India and subsequently recognized across all continents. Its eponymous origin dates to an 1893 study by Sir Thomas Henry Holland, who analyzed the tombstone of Jobโ€ฏCharnockโ€”the disputed โ€œfounderโ€ of Calcuttaโ€”in St.โ€ฏJohnโ€™s Churchyard, Kolkata, and determined the darkโ€‘gray to bluish rock represented a distinct petrological variety. In honor of Charnock, Holland proposed the term โ€œCharnockite,โ€ cementing a colonial legacy within geological nomenclature.

Petrography and Classification

Charnockites occupy a continuum between true granites and pyroxene granulites. Characterized by Kโ€‘feldspar, quartz, plagioclase, and hypersthene (orthopyroxene), they diverge from standard granitoids by their highโ€‘temperature, lowโ€‘water metamorphic history. Under the International Union of Geological Sciences (IUGS) scheme, classic Charnockite falls within the โ€œorthopyroxeneโ€ฏโ€“โ€ฏgraniteโ€ category, reflecting its unusual mineral assemblage that forms only under deep crustal conditions (>โ€ฏ700โ€ฏยฐC, 4โ€“7โ€ฏkbar).

Contested Colonial Legacy

Although first described at St.โ€ฏThomas Mount near Chennai, India, Charnockites occur in Archean to Proterozoic shield areas worldwideโ€”from the Kaapvaal Craton in South Africa to the Canadian Shield and parts of Scandinavia. Their presence signals ancient collisional orogenies and crustal thickening, offering valuable insights into Precambrian geodynamics. Geochemically, Charnockites often display high potassium and low silica relative to normal granites, indicating meltโ€“rock interactions at depth and later exhumation via extensional tectonics or erosion.

While the name โ€œCharnockiteโ€ honors a prominent Company official, modern scholars question the appropriateness of memorializing colonial figures in scientific taxonomy. Critics argue that geological terms should reflect mineralogical traits or indigenous toponyms rather than colonial administrators, whose actionsโ€”such as Charnockโ€™s contested founding of Calcuttaโ€”carry complex socioโ€‘political connotations. Efforts to decolonize science have prompted calls to adopt more descriptive or locally rooted nomenclature for such rock types.

Economic and Heritage Value

Beyond academic interest, Charnockites serve as dimension stones and ornamental granites in construction, prized for their durability and distinctive speckled appearance. In Chennai, historic Charnockite quarry sites near St.โ€ฏThomas Mount now constitute a geological heritage area, attracting both tourists and researchers. Proposals to designate classic Charnockite localities as Global Heritage Stone Resources are under consideration, underscoring their dual value as scientific typeโ€‘localities and cultural landmarks.

Charnockite remains a paradigmatic example of how geology interweaves natural history with human narratives. Its study continues to refine our understanding of crustal processes, while its name invites reflection on the intersection of colonial history and scientific practice. A balanced approach may preserve โ€œCharnockiteโ€ for its petrological precision, even as the geological community explores more inclusive naming conventions that honor both scientific and local heritage.


Sources

  • ‘Charnockite.’ In Britannica Encyclopedia.
  • Datta, Rangan. (2023). The discovery of Charnockite โ€“ the rock of Charnock. The Telegraph, August 24.
  • Haraniya, Krutika. (2017). Charnock: Linking Kolkata and a Rock. Peepul Tree. July 23.
  • Pichamuthu, C. S. (1972). Job Charnock and Charnockite.ย Journal Geological Society of India,ย 13(1), 86-91.
  • Sreejith, C., Del Lama, E. A., & Kaur, G. (2021). Charnockite: a candidate for โ€˜Global Heritage Stone Resourceโ€™ designation from India. Episodes Journal of International Geoscience44(1), 19-29.


search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close